William Scruton's Portrait of Emily Bronte

This image (left) was first published in 1898 as a portrait of Emily Bronte and has been reproduced many times since. It is actually based on a portrait of Anne Bronte.

The Bronte's ex-servant, Martha Brown, died in 1880 and her collection of Bronte relics were distributed amongst her family. A photo on glass of the 'Pillar Portrait' passed to her sister Tabitha Ratcliffe. The original 'Pillar Portrait' painting (right) was in Ireland, hidden away in the house of Charlotte's widower, Arthur Bell Nicholls, and was not discovered until 1914.

In 1897 Clement Shorter managed to obtain a copy of the photo of the Pillar Portrait  (below)but it appears that the identity of the sisters wasn't known. He sent a copy to Mr Nicholls, in Ireland and in March 1897 Nicholls replied:

"The photograph you enclosed does bear a resemblance to the picture of the three sisters - it is just possible that Martha Brown had it copied before we left Haworth - The likenesses are very bad - The left hand corner has something of the expression of Anne - The others I should not recognise." 

Left to right: Anne, Emily & Charlotte in an an early (retouched) photo of the Pillar Portrait.It was a poor image so some of the faces were retouched and Shorter used it to illustrate an article "Relics of Emily Bronte" in Woman at Home, August, 1897. This was the first time the portrait had been published.

The title reads in capitals: "SUPPOSED PORTRAITS OF EMILY AND ANNE BRONTE AND THEIR AUNT, MISS BRANWELL." which makes it appear that Emily is on the left but underneath in very small italics reads: "The portrait on the extreme left bears a certain resemblance to Anne Bronte."

This suggests that Clement Shorter thought the figure on the left to be Emily, hence the title, but felt that he had to include what he was told by Mr Nicholls, which is almost unreadable.

The figure on the far right is of course Charlotte Bronte, not Aunt Branwell. Mr Nicholl's refused to recognise any image of his wife other than the Richmond Portrait which he had authorised to be published in 1857.

The following year, in December 1898, the historian William Scruton published  his book 'Thornton and the Brontes'  with this portrait of Emily (left) which was:

"carefully and accurately copied by Miss Preston from a picture which came to me from Haworth with good credentials as to authenticity.

The original was submitted to the inspection of Martha Brown, the Brontë housekeeper, and admitted by her to be a tolerably faithful portrait. The picture formerly belonged to a member of the Brown family, of Haworth, who always regarded it as a good likeness.

On the strength of this evidence, and notwithstanding Mr.Shorter's opinion that the quest for an authentic portrait of Emily Brontë now seems hopeless, I have felt justified in giving the portrait a prominent place in my book."

This text is quite misleading:

Was the "picture which came to me from Haworth" a painting or the photo?

Whatever it was, it originates from the photo of the Pillar Portrait published in 1897. The evidence for this is in the blemish - a dark patch - above Anne's head in the photo. This has been mistaken by the artist for her hair and is drawn as a bun. The blemish doesn't appear in the original portrait painting (right).

"The original" seems to be the "Photo on glass of the Pillar Portrait" which wasn't "submitted to the inspection of Martha Brown" because she actually owned the photo. Martha wouldn't have seen Miss Preston's portrait as it was created in 1897-8 and Martha had died some 17 years earlier, in 1880.

The "picture [which] formerly belonged to a member of the Brown family" was the photo, not the original portrait painting, as that was with Mr Nicholls in Ireland.

Historians at this date were unaware that this was the "Pillar Portrait" described by Elizabeth Gaskell in 1857; she identified the sisters left to right as Anne, Emily and Charlotte.

Publication of this portrait over the past century has led many people to believe that Emily had an aquiline nose.

Left: Anne in the original 'Pillar Portrait.' Right: The illustration of 1898.